Microbiome learning path · Chapter 8
Why you should include fermented foods in your diet
Fermented foods are made when bacteria or yeasts transform a food, as in curd, buttermilk, idli and dosa batter, dhokla and kanji. Fermentation makes food easier to digest and, when the food is eaten uncooked, supplies live microbes. In one trial, a diet rich in fermented foods increased the variety of gut bacteria and lowered markers of inflammation. A serving or two a day is a reasonable habit for most people.
In short
- Fermentation is one of the oldest ways of preparing food, and Indian cooking is rich in it.
- Fermented foods and probiotics are not the same thing.
- Uncooked fermented foods such as curd and buttermilk contain live microbes. Cooked ones such as idli do not, but are still easier to digest.
- In a trial, a diet rich in fermented foods raised the variety of gut bacteria and lowered markers of inflammation.
- The benefit may not depend only on live microbes. In a small study, pasteurised and unpasteurised sauerkraut helped equally.
- Kefir and kombucha have very little human evidence. Curd and buttermilk do the same job.
- Boil milk before setting curd. Raw milk carries a real risk of infection.
- Start with small amounts. People with weak immunity should avoid unpasteurised home ferments.
What is fermentation?
Microbes feed on the sugars in a food and convert them to acids, gases or alcohol. This sours milk into curd, raises idli batter and gives pickles their tang. Along the way it breaks down some of the lactose in milk and some of the hard-to-digest carbohydrates in grains and pulses, and it produces new flavours and compounds.
An international expert panel defines fermented foods as foods made through desired microbial growth and the conversion of food components by enzymes. “Desired” is the important word: fermentation is controlled spoilage, by microbes that people have chosen over centuries.
Are fermented foods the same as probiotics?
No. A probiotic is a defined strain of live microbe, given in a known amount, that has been shown in studies to benefit health. Fermented foods contain a varying mix of microbes, most of which have not been studied in that way. Some, such as bread and cooked batters, contain no live microbes by the time they are eaten. Fermented foods are still worth eating; the two simply should not be confused. See what probiotics are.
Which Indian foods are fermented?
| Food | Live microbes when eaten? | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Curd (dahi), buttermilk, lassi | Yes | Home-set curd varies from batch to batch; lower in lactose than milk |
| Idli, dosa, appam, dhokla | No, they are cooked | Fermentation improves digestibility |
| Kanji (fermented carrot or beetroot drink) | Yes | Traditional in north India |
| Fermented rice (pazhaya sadam, panta bhat) | Yes | Rice soaked overnight |
| Ambali (fermented ragi) | Yes | Traditional in Karnataka |
| Naturally fermented pickles | Sometimes | Many pickles are preserved in oil, salt or vinegar and are not fermented |
Live or not. Both lists are worth eating. Only the first supplies live microbes.
Are pickles fermented?
Some are. It depends on how they are made.
Two kinds of pickle. Only the first is a fermented food.
A pickle kept in salt water sours slowly, because bacteria on the vegetable make the acid. That is fermentation, as in kanji. A pickle made by adding vinegar, or one preserved in oil and salt, is preserved without fermentation. Most Indian oil pickles are of the second kind. They are a good relish and a salty one, not a source of live microbes.
What does the research show?
Gut bacteria
In a ten-week trial, adults who ate a diet high in fermented foods developed a more diverse population of gut bacteria and had lower levels of several inflammatory markers.
Lactose digestion
The bacteria in curd help to digest its lactose, so people who are uncomfortable with milk often tolerate curd.
General health
Studies that follow large groups over time link regular yoghurt and fermented dairy with better metabolic health. These studies show association, not proof of cause.
Fermented foods are part of a healthy diet. They are not a treatment for any disease.
What did the diet trial find?
It is the most careful trial so far, and it compared fermented foods with fibre.
Healthy adults were randomly assigned to eat more fermented foods or more fibre, with 18 people in each group.
Two diets, different effects. Fermented foods raised the variety of gut bacteria. Fibre fed the bacteria already there.
- Fermented foods: the variety of gut bacteria rose steadily, and several markers of inflammation in the blood fell.
- Fibre: the bacteria gained more enzymes for digesting fibre, but their variety did not rise in that time.
The two are not rivals. Fibre feeds the residents and fermented foods add passing visitors. The plate needs both. See fibre and the Indian plate.
The trial was small and lasted weeks. It measured bacteria and blood markers, not illness.
Do the microbes need to be alive?
Perhaps less than we assume.
In a pilot trial, 34 people with irritable bowel syndrome ate either unpasteurised sauerkraut, with live bacteria, or pasteurised sauerkraut, with none, for six weeks. Symptoms improved in both groups, with no difference between them. Gut bacteria changed in both. The researchers concluded that the effect probably came more from the food’s prebiotic content than from its live bacteria, and noted that the study was too small to be sure.
For an Indian kitchen this is reassuring. Idli, dosa and dhokla are cooked, so their microbes are dead, but the batter has been changed by fermentation. They are still good food for the gut.
What about kefir and kombucha?
Both are promoted far beyond what has been tested.
Kefir
A fermented milk drink. A review found 16 trials in people, and judged 12 of them to be at high risk of bias. It concluded that kefir appears safe for healthy people and that no health recommendation can yet be made.
Kombucha
A fermented sweet tea. A review that screened 310 articles found one study in people. The claims made for it come from laboratory and animal work.
Neither is harmful for most healthy people in ordinary amounts. Neither has been shown to do anything that curd, buttermilk or kanji does not, and those are already in most Indian kitchens. Kombucha is also a sweetened drink.
How do I add them to my diet?
- Begin with one serving a day, such as a small bowl of curd or a glass of buttermilk with lunch
- Build up to two or three servings, of different kinds
- Have them alongside fibre-rich food, which feeds the microbes
- Choose plain curd over sweetened, flavoured products
- When fermenting at home, use clean vessels and discard anything with an off smell or visible mould
Who should take care?
- People with weakened immunity, including those on chemotherapy or after a transplant, should avoid unpasteurised home ferments and ask their doctor first
- People with high blood pressure should limit salty pickles
- People who get flushing, headaches or hives after fermented or aged foods may be sensitive to histamine
- People with IBS or bacterial overgrowth sometimes feel more bloated at first. Start with small amounts
Is raw milk or home fermenting safe?
Home fermenting is safe when it starts from safe ingredients. Raw milk is not one of them.
In the United States, unpasteurised milk and cheese were consumed by a small share of people but caused 96% of the illness from contaminated dairy products. The researchers estimated that unpasteurised dairy caused 840 times more illness than pasteurised dairy. The bacteria involved cause serious infections, which are most dangerous in pregnancy, in young children and in older people.
The Indian habit of boiling milk before setting curd removes this risk.
Curd at home. Boiling first is what makes home-set curd safe.
For other home ferments, use clean vessels, keep the food under its liquid, and discard anything with visible mould or an off smell. See leftover and reheated food for how fermented foods differ from food that has simply been left out.
From my practice
I ask most patients to keep one fermented food on the table every day, and I tell them it does not need to be exotic. A bowl of home-set curd or a glass of buttermilk with lunch is enough. Patients who cannot take milk often manage curd.
When someone tells me they have started kefir or kombucha for their gut, I do not object, but I ask what they stopped eating to make room for it. If the answer is curd and dal, they have made a poor exchange.
| What this page says | How it is known |
|---|---|
| Fermented foods raised the variety of gut bacteria and lowered inflammatory markers | A randomised trial, 18 adults in each group |
| More fibre did not raise variety in the same trial | The same trial |
| Pasteurised and unpasteurised sauerkraut helped IBS symptoms equally | A pilot trial in 34 patients |
| Kefir cannot yet be recommended for any condition | A review of 16 trials, most at high risk of bias |
| Kombucha has almost no evidence in people | A review that found one human study |
| Unpasteurised dairy causes far more illness than pasteurised | An estimate from outbreak data in the United States |
| Curd is easier to digest than milk | Reviews of lactose digestion |
Questions patients ask me
Is home-made curd a probiotic?
It contains live bacteria and is a healthy fermented food. It is not a probiotic in the strict sense, because the strains and their amounts are not defined or tested.
Does cooking idli and dosa remove the benefit?
Steaming or frying kills the microbes, but the batter has already been changed by fermentation, which makes it lighter and easier to digest.
How much should I eat each day?
One to three servings suits most people. There is no fixed requirement.
Is it better to take a probiotic capsule?
For general health, fermented foods and fibre do more. Probiotic capsules have a place in a few specific conditions.
Sources
This page is written for patients and is based on the guidelines and studies below. It is for education and does not replace a consultation.
- International consensus statement on fermented foods. Marco ML et al. Nat Rev Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2021. PubMed 33398112
- Trial of high-fibre and fermented-food diets and immune status. Wastyk HC et al. Cell. 2021. PubMed 34256014
- International consensus statement on the term probiotic. Hill C et al. Nat Rev Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2014. PubMed 24912386
- Review of lactose malabsorption and intolerance. Misselwitz B et al. Gut. 2019. PubMed 31427404
- Review of how yoghurt bacteria help lactose digestion. Savaiano DA. Am J Clin Nutr. 2014. PubMed 24695892
- Randomised pilot trial of pasteurised and unpasteurised sauerkraut in 34 people with irritable bowel syndrome. Nielsen ES et al. Food Funct. 2018. doi:10.1039/c8fo00968f
- Systematic review of randomised trials of kefir and human health. Kairey L et al. Nutr Rev. 2023. doi:10.1093/nutrit/nuac054
- Systematic review of the evidence for kombucha in people. Kapp JM, Sumner W. Ann Epidemiol. 2019. doi:10.1016/j.annepidem.2018.11.001
- Estimate of outbreak illness from unpasteurised milk and cheese in the United States. Costard S et al. Emerg Infect Dis. 2017. doi:10.3201/eid2306.151603
- Review of histamine intolerance. Comas-Baste O et al. Biomolecules. 2020. doi:10.3390/biom10081181