Food and the gut
Leftover and reheated food: is it bad for the gut?
Food cooked yesterday is not harmful because it is old. It becomes harmful when it has been kept warm for hours, which lets bacteria multiply. Cooled quickly, stored in the refrigerator and reheated until steaming, leftovers are safe. Rice needs particular care. There is also a small benefit: rice and potatoes that have been cooked and cooled contain more resistant starch, which feeds gut bacteria. Tradition prefers fresh food, and in a hot climate without a refrigerator that was sound advice.
In short
- The risk in leftovers is time spent warm, not age alone.
- Cool cooked food quickly and refrigerate it within two hours.
- Reheat it until it is steaming hot all the way through, and reheat it only once.
- Cooked rice left out overnight is a well-known cause of food poisoning.
- Stored food builds up histamine. People who are sensitive to histamine should eat freshly cooked food and avoid leftovers.
- Cooked and cooled rice, potatoes and pulses contain more resistant starch, which gut bacteria use.
What does Ayurveda say?
As Ayurveda describes it
- Ayurveda advises food that is freshly cooked, warm and eaten soon after it is made.
- Food kept overnight is called paryushita and is to be avoided, as is food that has been reheated.
- Stale food is described as heavy, hard to digest and a cause of disease.
How this may work. The rule was made for a hot country without refrigeration, and there it is exactly right. Bacteria multiply in cooked food kept warm, and some produce toxins that reheating does not destroy. Refrigeration changes the picture: it holds bacteria back, which is why the studies below find properly stored leftovers to be safe.
Why can leftovers make you ill?
Cooking kills most bacteria. Some survive as hardy spores, and others arrive afterwards from hands, spoons and the air. Between about 5°C and 60°C they multiply. In a warm Indian kitchen their numbers can double many times in a few hours.
Some of these bacteria make toxins. Reheating kills the bacteria but does not always destroy the toxin.
Why is rice a special case?
Uncooked rice often carries the spores of a bacterium that survives boiling. If cooked rice stands at room temperature, the spores wake, multiply and produce a toxin that causes vomiting within a few hours of eating. Frying or reheating the rice does not remove that toxin.
This is the reason behind many cases of “food poisoning from fried rice”. The answer is to cool rice quickly and refrigerate it, not to keep the pot on the counter until the next meal.
What are the rules for storing and reheating?
- 2 hours is the longest cooked food should stay at room temperature
- Below 5°C is the temperature for storing it
- Once is how many times to reheat it
Cool it quickly
Spread food in shallow containers so that it cools fast. Do not wait for a large pot to cool on the stove.
Refrigerate within two hours
Sooner in very hot weather. Cover the containers.
Use it within a few days
Do not keep leftovers in the refrigerator for long. If in doubt, throw it out.
Reheat until steaming hot throughout
Stir while reheating so that there are no cold spots. Bring dals and gravies to a boil.
Reheat only the portion you will eat
Repeated warming and cooling gives bacteria repeated chances.
Three zones. Bacteria multiply between 5°C and 60°C, so cooked food should spend little time there.
These follow the World Health Organization’s guidance on safe food.
Who should avoid leftovers?
Histamine is a natural substance that bacteria form in food from the moment it is cooked. The amount rises with every hour of storage, fastest in fish, meat and other protein foods, and it rises in the refrigerator too, though more slowly. Reheating does not remove it.
Histamine and storage. A sketch of direction only: it rises with time, more slowly in the refrigerator, and stops when food is frozen.
Most people break histamine down in the gut without noticing. Some do not break it down well. For them, food that has been stored can bring on flushing, headache, itching, a blocked nose, bloating, cramps or loose stools within an hour or two of eating.
If you are sensitive to histamine
- Eat food freshly cooked, and avoid leftovers.
- If food must be kept, cool it quickly and freeze it straight away. Freezing stops histamine from forming. Refrigeration only slows it.
- Be most careful with fish, meat, slow-cooked broths and food that has stood at a buffet.
- This is also the group for whom the Ayurvedic rule of fresh food applies most strictly.
Is there any benefit in cooled food?
When rice, potatoes and pulses are cooked and then cooled, part of their starch changes into a form called resistant starch. It is not digested in the small intestine. It reaches the colon, where bacteria ferment it. In a trial, rice that had been cooked, cooled and reheated raised blood sugar less than freshly cooked rice.
So yesterday’s rice, properly refrigerated, is a reasonable food.
What about fermented and traditional foods?
Idli and dosa batter, curd, kanji and pickles are kept on purpose. Their own bacteria and the acid they produce hold harmful bacteria back. They are a different matter from plain cooked food left out. See fermented foods.
Questions patients ask me
Is food from the refrigerator less nutritious than fresh food?
Slightly, for some vitamins. The difference is small compared with the benefit of eating home-cooked food at all.
Can I eat rice soaked overnight in water?
Fermented rice is a traditional food in several parts of India. Its safety depends on clean water and on the fermentation taking hold. If you did not grow up preparing it, refrigerated rice is the safer choice.
Does reheated food cause gas or acidity?
Not because it is reheated. Cooled starchy food has more resistant starch, which some people with a sensitive bowel notice as gas.
I feel unwell after eating food that has been stored for days. Why?
Stored food builds up histamine, and some people are sensitive to it. If this happens to you regularly, eat freshly cooked food and avoid leftovers.
Sources
This page is written for patients and is based on the guidelines and studies below. It is for education and does not replace a consultation.
- World Health Organization: Five keys to safer food manual. World Health Organization. 2006. www.who.int
- Study of Bacillus cereus growth in cooked rice and food poisoning. Gilbert RJ et al. J Hyg (Lond). 1974. doi:10.1017/s0022172400042790
- Trial of cooled and reheated rice, resistant starch and blood sugar. Sonia S et al. Asia Pac J Clin Nutr. 2015. doi:10.6133/apjcn.2015.24.4.13
- Review of resistant starch and health. Birt DF et al. Adv Nutr. 2013. doi:10.3945/an.113.004325
- Review of histamine intolerance and how it is diagnosed. Hrubisko M et al. Nutrients. 2021. doi:10.3390/nu13072228
- German, Swiss and Austrian allergy societies’ guideline on reactions to histamine in food. Reese I et al. Allergol Select. 2021. doi:10.5414/ALX02269E
- American College of Gastroenterology guideline on acute diarrhoeal infections in adults. Riddle MS et al. Am J Gastroenterol. 2016. doi:10.1038/ajg.2016.126