Microbiome learning path · Chapter 7
Fat, protein and sugar: what they do to gut bacteria
Fibre feeds gut bacteria directly. Fat, protein and sugar act on them in quieter ways: through the bile that fat brings down, through the protein that escapes digestion, and through what a sugary diet leaves out. This chapter covers what trials in people have found, including the compound called TMAO that links red meat, gut bacteria and the heart. It also covers three things patients often ask about: iron tablets, vitamin D and going gluten-free without coeliac disease.
In short
- Fat is absorbed before it reaches the colon, but a fatty meal sends more bile down to the bacteria.
- Protein that escapes digestion is fermented in the colon. In a trial, extra protein changed what the bacteria produced without changing which bacteria were present.
- Gut bacteria turn compounds in red meat and eggs into TMAO. Higher TMAO in the blood went with more heart attacks and strokes in a large study.
- Sugar is absorbed early. Its main harm to gut bacteria is what a sugary diet leaves out: fibre.
- Iron that is not absorbed reaches the colon and can favour harmful bacteria. Iron deficiency still needs treating.
- Going gluten-free without coeliac disease removes wheat’s fibre, and bifidobacteria fell in a small study.
What reaches the colon from a meal?
Less than most people imagine. The small intestine absorbs nearly all the fat, most of the protein and almost all the sugar. What the colon’s bacteria receive depends on what is left.
From plate to colon. Fibre feeds gut bacteria directly. Fat, protein and sugar reach them indirectly.
That is why the effects of fat, protein and sugar on gut bacteria are smaller and less consistent than the effect of fibre, and why much of this chapter is about indirect routes.
What does fat do to gut bacteria?
Mostly it acts through bile. The liver releases bile to digest fat. A meal high in fat brings more bile into the gut, more of it reaches the colon, and bacteria change it into secondary bile acids. See chapter 1.
What has been shown in people:
- In five days. When volunteers ate an entirely animal-based diet, high in fat and with no fibre, bile-tolerant bacteria increased within days. The change faded when the diet ended.
- Over six months. In a feeding trial in healthy young adults, a higher-fat, lower-carbohydrate diet produced changes in stool bile acids that the researchers considered potentially unfavourable for the colon.
- All the trials together. A systematic review found six trials and nine observational studies. The trials did not suggest strong effects of the amount or type of fat on gut bacteria. High intakes of fat, and of saturated fat, may lower the variety of bacteria. The reviewers noted that the data were inconsistent and that most studies had risks of bias.
So the evidence in people is modest. It points the same way as the advice for the heart: a moderate amount of fat, more of it unsaturated. For individual oils and ghee, see cooking oils, ghee and the gut.
What happens to protein in the colon?
Most protein is digested and absorbed in the small intestine. The part that escapes is fermented by bacteria in the colon. Fermenting protein yields different products from fermenting fibre.
In a double-blind trial, 38 overweight adults were given extra milk protein, extra soya protein or a control for three weeks.
- The make-up of their gut bacteria did not change.
- The activity of the bacteria did. It shifted towards breaking down amino acids, and the products differed between milk protein and soya protein.
- There was no inflammation. The activity of some genes in the lining of the rectum changed, and the researchers said this raised new questions about high-protein diets and the colon.
This is a short trial. It does not show harm. It does show that a diet can change what gut bacteria do without changing who they are, which a stool report would miss entirely.
A practical reading: bacteria prefer fibre. When fibre is plentiful, they ferment it first. Dal, rajma, chana and sprouts bring protein and fibre together, which is one reason pulses suit the gut.
What is TMAO, and does it matter?
TMAO is the most studied example of gut bacteria turning food into something that affects the heart.
How TMAO is made. Without gut bacteria, the first step does not happen.
Red meat and eggs contain carnitine and choline. Certain gut bacteria convert these into a compound called TMA. The liver then converts TMA into TMAO, which circulates in the blood.
What the human studies show:
It needs bacteria
When volunteers were given antibiotics, their TMAO fell sharply. It returned when the antibiotics were stopped.
It tracks with heart disease
Among 4,007 people followed for three years, those with the highest TMAO had about two and a half times the risk of death, heart attack or stroke of those with the lowest.
Meat-eaters make more
Given the same amount of carnitine, people who ate meat produced more TMAO than vegans and vegetarians.
Red meat raises it
In a feeding trial of 113 volunteers, four weeks of a red-meat diet more than doubled TMAO. White meat and non-meat protein did not.
Two cautions. These studies show that TMAO goes with heart disease; they do not prove that TMAO causes it. And TMAO is not a clinic test. Nobody should have it measured or take a supplement to lower it.
What it adds is a mechanism for older advice: large amounts of red meat are linked with heart disease, and gut bacteria may be part of the reason.
What does sugar do to gut bacteria?
Less directly than people think, because very little sugar normally reaches the colon.
The sharpest evidence is from mice. Mice given sugar in their drinking water developed more of the bacteria that eat mucus. The mucus layer of the colon thinned, and the mice developed worse colitis. Mice without gut bacteria were protected, which shows the bacteria were responsible.
In mice. Sugar favoured mucus-eating bacteria and thinned the protective layer.
This has not been shown in the same way in people. See how to judge a gut-health claim.
What has been shown in people is the effect of the diet that sugar comes in. When volunteers lived in a research unit and ate an ultra-processed diet, they ate about 500 kcal a day more than on an unprocessed diet, and gained weight. Sweets, biscuits and sweet drinks displace vegetables, pulses and whole grains, and with them the fibre that gut bacteria live on.
For where sugar hides in an Indian diet and how to cut down, see sugar and gut health.
Are sweeteners any better for gut bacteria?
Not clearly. In a trial of 120 healthy adults, four intense sweeteners changed gut bacteria within two weeks, and the effect differed from person to person. The full account, including sugar alcohols and what the World Health Organization advises, is in artificial sweeteners and gut bacteria.
Do iron tablets affect gut bacteria?
They can. Iron is poorly absorbed, so much of what is swallowed travels on to the colon. Many harmful bacteria need iron to grow.
Iron in the gut. The part that is not absorbed reaches the bacteria.
In two trials in 115 Kenyan infants, iron-fortified food powders increased the harmful strains of E. coli and other enterobacteria in the gut, and raised a stool marker of inflammation. In a later trial, adding a prebiotic fibre to a lower amount of iron prevented most of these changes, and anaemia still fell.
Two points must be kept together:
- Iron deficiency is common in India and must be treated. Anaemia harms growth, pregnancy and energy. Nothing here is a reason to refuse iron.
- Iron should be taken for a reason, in the form and amount a doctor chooses. If iron tablets give you constipation, loose stools or pain, say so. There are alternatives.
See also the section on iron in prebiotics: a doctor’s guide.
Does vitamin D affect gut bacteria?
Possibly. In a study of 80 healthy women who were deficient in vitamin D, supplements were followed by a more varied community of gut bacteria and more of two groups often regarded as helpful. Women whose vitamin D rose well showed larger changes than those whose levels did not respond.
The study compared before with after and had no comparison group, so other explanations are possible. It is a reason to correct a deficiency that has been found by a blood test. It is not a reason to take vitamin D for the gut.
Should I go gluten-free if I do not have coeliac disease?
Not for the sake of your gut bacteria.
Wheat’s fibre goes too. Removing gluten also removes one of the main prebiotic fibres in the diet.
- In a small study, 10 healthy adults ate a gluten-free diet for a month. Bifidobacteria and lactobacilli fell, and enterobacteria rose.
- In a crossover trial, 60 Danish adults without coeliac disease ate a low-gluten diet and a high-gluten diet for eight weeks each. The low-gluten diet brought moderate changes in gut bacteria and less bloating. The researchers concluded that most of the effects probably came from the change in fibre, not from the gluten.
So feeling less bloated without wheat is real for some people, and the likely reason is wheat’s fermentable fibre, a FODMAP. See the low FODMAP diet.
If you suspect a problem with wheat, get tested for coeliac disease before you stop eating it. The tests are unreliable once gluten is out of the diet. See gluten sensitivity in India.
So what should I eat?
The single nutrients matter less than the pattern.
Keep fibre at the centre
It is the one part of the diet that feeds gut bacteria directly. See fibre and the Indian plate.
Take protein with its fibre
Pulses, sprouts, curd with vegetables. If you eat meat or fish, put vegetables beside it.
Keep red meat occasional
Fish, eggs, chicken and pulses on most days.
Use a moderate amount of oil
Measured with a spoon, and mostly unsaturated.
Keep sweets and packaged snacks for occasions
What they displace matters as much as what they contain.
Take supplements for a reason
Iron and vitamin D when a test shows you need them.
From my practice
The question I am asked most often is whether a food is “good or bad for the gut”. For fat, protein and sugar the fair answer is that the amount and the company matter more than the food. A plate with dal, vegetables and a little ghee is a different thing from the same ghee on a plate of maida.
I also see many people who have stopped wheat on their own and feel a little better. Before anything else I ask whether they were tested for coeliac disease first. If they were not, we have a problem to untangle, because the test needs gluten in the diet.
| What this page says | How it is known |
|---|---|
| Trials do not show strong effects of fat on gut bacteria | A systematic review of 6 trials and 9 observational studies |
| An animal-based diet raised bile-tolerant bacteria within days | A controlled human feeding study |
| Extra protein changed bacterial activity, not make-up | A double-blind trial in 38 adults |
| High TMAO went with more heart attacks, strokes and deaths | A study of 4,007 patients over three years |
| Red meat more than doubled TMAO | A feeding trial in 113 volunteers |
| Sugar thinned the mucus layer and worsened colitis | Mice |
| Iron fortification increased harmful gut bacteria | Two trials in 115 Kenyan infants |
| Vitamin D was followed by a more varied gut community | A before-and-after study in 80 women |
| A gluten-free diet lowered bifidobacteria | A study of 10 healthy adults |
| Low-gluten effects probably come from fibre | A crossover trial in 60 adults |
Who should be careful?
- Heart disease or high cholesterol: follow your cardiologist’s advice on meat, eggs and fat.
- Kidney disease: protein is set by your kidney doctor.
- Gallstones, reflux or pancreatic disease: large fatty meals bring on symptoms.
- Anaemia: do not stop iron on your own. Ask about the form and timing.
- Suspected coeliac disease: test first, then change the diet.
When should I see a doctor?
See a doctor for tiredness and pallor that could mean anaemia, for bloating or loose stools that last more than three to four weeks, and promptly for weight loss, blood in the stool or black stools.
Questions patients ask me
Is a high-protein diet bad for the gut?
The trial of extra protein found no inflammation over three weeks. It did change what gut bacteria produced. Long-term effects are not known. Keep fibre in the diet whatever your protein intake.
Should I stop eating eggs because of TMAO?
No. The feeding trial found the rise with red meat, not with white meat or non-meat protein. Eggs in moderation are a reasonable food. If you have heart disease, follow your cardiologist.
Is jaggery or honey better for gut bacteria than sugar?
They are mostly the same sugars, absorbed in the same way. I am not aware of a trial showing a benefit for gut bacteria. Use them for taste, in small amounts.
My iron tablet upsets my stomach. Can I stop it?
Do not stop it without asking. Tell your doctor. A different form, a different time of day or a different schedule often solves it.
Will vitamin D improve my gut bacteria?
One study suggests it may in people who are deficient. Correct a deficiency if a blood test shows one. That is the reason to take it.
I feel better without wheat. Do I have gluten intolerance?
Perhaps, or you may be reacting to wheat’s fermentable fibre. The first step is a coeliac test, done while you are still eating wheat.
Sources
This page is written for patients and is based on the guidelines and studies below. It is for education and does not replace a consultation.
- Systematic review of dietary fat, gut bacteria and metabolic health in people. Wolters M et al. Clin Nutr. 2019. doi:10.1016/j.clnu.2018.12.024
- Six-month feeding trial of a higher-fat diet, bile acids and gut bacteria. Wan Y et al. Clin Nutr. 2020. doi:10.1016/j.clnu.2019.02.037
- Study of how quickly diet changes the gut microbiome. David LA et al. Nature. 2014. PubMed 24336217
- Randomised double-blind trial of extra milk or soya protein and gut bacteria in 38 overweight adults. Beaumont M et al. Am J Clin Nutr. 2017. doi:10.3945/ajcn.117.158816
- Study of TMAO and cardiovascular events in 4,007 patients over three years. Tang WH et al. N Engl J Med. 2013. doi:10.1056/NEJMoa1109400
- Study of carnitine, gut bacteria and TMAO in people and mice. Koeth RA et al. Nat Med. 2013. doi:10.1038/nm.3145
- Randomised feeding trial of red meat, white meat and non-meat protein and TMAO in 113 volunteers. Wang Z et al. Eur Heart J. 2019. doi:10.1093/eurheartj/ehy799
- Study of simple sugars, gut bacteria and colitis in mice. Khan S et al. Sci Transl Med. 2020. doi:10.1126/scitranslmed.aay6218
- Inpatient randomised trial of ultra-processed and unprocessed diets. Hall KD et al. Cell Metab. 2019. doi:10.1016/j.cmet.2019.05.008
- Systematic reviews of carbohydrate quality and human health. Reynolds A et al. Lancet. 2019. PubMed 30638909
- Randomised trial of four non-sugar sweeteners in 120 healthy adults. Suez J et al. Cell. 2022. doi:10.1016/j.cell.2022.07.016
- Two randomised trials of iron fortification and the gut microbiome in 115 Kenyan infants. Jaeggi T et al. Gut. 2015. doi:10.1136/gutjnl-2014-307720
- Randomised trial of galacto-oligosaccharides with iron fortification in 155 Kenyan infants. Paganini D et al. Gut. 2017. doi:10.1136/gutjnl-2017-314418
- Before-and-after study of vitamin D and gut bacteria in 80 deficient women. Singh P et al. Sci Rep. 2020. doi:10.1038/s41598-020-77806-4
- Study of a gluten-free diet and gut bacteria in 10 healthy adults. De Palma G et al. Br J Nutr. 2009. doi:10.1017/S0007114509371767
- Randomised crossover trial of a low-gluten diet in 60 Danish adults. Hansen LBS et al. Nat Commun. 2018. doi:10.1038/s41467-018-07019-x