Microbiome learning path · Chapter 6
Colour, spice and polyphenols: the other food of gut bacteria
Fibre is not the only part of a plant that reaches your gut bacteria. The compounds that give plants their colour, bitterness and bite, called polyphenols, arrive in the colon largely undigested. Bacteria break them into smaller compounds that the body can absorb, and the polyphenols in turn change which bacteria thrive. People differ in what their bacteria make from the same food. This chapter covers where polyphenols are found on an Indian plate, what tea, coffee, cocoa and spices have shown in trials, and why a capsule is not the same as the food.
In short
- Polyphenols are the plant compounds behind colour, bitterness and astringency. Tea, coffee, cocoa, fruit, vegetables, pulses, whole grains and spices all carry them.
- Only a small part is absorbed in the small intestine. Most reaches the colon, where bacteria break it into smaller compounds.
- The traffic runs both ways: polyphenols also change which gut bacteria thrive.
- People differ. From the same pomegranate or walnut, some people’s bacteria make useful compounds and some make none.
- Tea and coffee with a meal reduce the iron absorbed from plant foods. This matters in India, where iron deficiency is common.
- Food and drink are safe sources. Concentrated extracts are different, and some have caused liver injury.
What are polyphenols?
They are a large family of compounds that plants make to protect themselves from sunlight, insects and infection. To us they are the purple of jamun, the yellow of turmeric, the bitterness of tea and the dryness that black tea or raw banana leaves in the mouth.
There are thousands of them. Scientists group them into four main families:
Flavonoids
The largest family. Found in tea, onion, cocoa, citrus fruit, berries and soya.
Phenolic acids
Found in coffee, whole grains and many fruits.
Stilbenes
A small family, found mainly in grapes.
Lignans
Found in flaxseed, sesame and whole grains.
Polyphenols are not vitamins. There is no deficiency disease and no daily requirement. Their interest lies in what gut bacteria do with them.
Where do polyphenols go in the body?
Not where most people assume. A review of how polyphenols are absorbed found that this differs greatly from one compound to another, and that the most abundant ones in food are not the most readily absorbed.
The small intestine takes up only a small part. The rest travels on to the colon, where bacteria break the large molecules into smaller ones. Those smaller compounds are then absorbed, pass through the liver and circulate in the blood.
The journey. Most of a polyphenol’s story happens in the colon, and gut bacteria write it.
So when a study reports that a food “contains” a certain polyphenol, that is only the starting point. What reaches your blood is largely what your bacteria made from it.
How do polyphenols and gut bacteria affect each other?
In both directions.
Bacteria change polyphenols. They cut large molecules into smaller, absorbable ones. Without bacteria, much of what we eat in this family would simply pass through.
Polyphenols change bacteria. They favour some groups and hold others back. For this reason the international panel that defines prebiotics lists polyphenols as candidate prebiotics, alongside the fermentable fibres.
What has been shown in people:
- Cocoa. In a crossover trial, 22 healthy volunteers drank a cocoa drink high in flavanols for four weeks and one low in flavanols for four weeks. On the high-flavanol drink, bifidobacteria and lactobacilli increased and clostridia fell.
- Coffee. In 16 healthy adults who drank three cups of coffee a day for three weeks, bifidobacteria increased, while the overall community changed little. There was no comparison group.
- Mixed spices. In a small pilot trial, spices in ordinary cooking amounts shifted the mix of gut bacteria. See Indian spices and the gut.
These are small, short studies that measured bacteria, not health. They show that the effect is real. They do not show how much it matters.
Where are polyphenols on an Indian plate?
Almost everywhere, if the plate has colour. Different colours come from different compounds, so a mix of colours brings a mix of polyphenols.
Colour on the plate. A simple way to think about variety through the week.
| Colour | Indian foods | What they contain |
|---|---|---|
| Red and purple | Pomegranate, jamun, black grapes, brinjal skin, red cabbage | Pigments of the flavonoid family; pomegranate also contains the compounds that become urolithins |
| Yellow and orange | Turmeric, orange, mosambi, papaya | Curcumin in turmeric; flavonoids in citrus |
| Green | Leafy greens, coriander, mint, curry leaves, green tea | Flavonoids and phenolic acids |
| Brown | Tea, coffee, cocoa, ragi, pulses with their skins on, whole spices | Flavonoids, phenolic acids and tannins |
| White | Onion, garlic, sesame, flaxseed | Flavonoids in onion; lignans in sesame and flaxseed |
Three practical points follow.
- Much of it is in the skin. The skin of a pulse, a brinjal or a fruit carries more than the flesh. Whole pulses and unpeeled fruit keep it.
- Polished grains have lost theirs with the bran. See fibre and the Indian plate.
- Variety counts. In a large citizen-science study, people who ate more than 30 different plants a week had more diverse gut bacteria than those who ate 10 or fewer.
What about tea and coffee?
Tea and coffee are the largest sources of polyphenols for many Indian adults, simply because they are drunk every day.
In moderation they suit most people. The coffee study above found more bifidobacteria after three weeks. For people with reflux, coffee can worsen heartburn.
One effect deserves attention in India. Polyphenols bind iron in the gut. In a study that measured iron absorption directly, every drink tested, including black tea, coffee, cocoa and several herb teas, reduced the iron absorbed from a bread meal. Black tea reduced it by 79 to 94%. Adding milk made little or no difference.
Tea, coffee and iron. The effect is on iron from plant foods eaten at the same time.
This applies to the iron in plant foods and in iron tablets, which is the kind most vegetarians depend on. If your iron is low, or you are pregnant, or you are taking iron tablets:
- Keep tea and coffee away from main meals
- Do not take an iron tablet with tea or coffee
Coffee also reduces the absorption of thyroid hormone tablets when the two are taken together.
What about spices?
Spices are concentrated sources of polyphenols, eaten in small amounts many times a day. Turmeric, cloves, cinnamon, cumin and black pepper all carry them.
A few spices have been tested for digestion in their own right. Ginger helps the stomach to empty, and turmeric’s main compound has been compared with an acid-blocker in indigestion. The details, and the Ayurvedic view of each spice, are in Indian spices and the gut.
For gut bacteria the evidence is early: one pilot trial of mixed spices at cooking amounts. Spices in food are safe. Spice extracts in capsules are discussed below.
Has a polyphenol-rich diet been tested?
Yes, once, with care.
In a crossover trial, 66 adults aged 60 and over were given a diet rich in polyphenols for eight weeks and a control diet for eight weeks, in random order. Fifty-one completed it. The polyphenol-rich diet was built from foods and drinks, not capsules.
After the polyphenol-rich diet:
- A blood marker linked with a leakier gut lining fell. The marker itself is debated.
- Blood pressure fell
- Bacteria that ferment fibre and make butyrate increased
This is one trial, in older people, over eight weeks. It measured markers, not illness.
A much-quoted experiment in mice found that a cranberry extract protected the animals from the effects of a high-fat, high-sugar diet and increased a mucus-living bacterium called Akkermansia. That is a mouse finding, and it has not been shown in people in the same way. See how to judge a gut-health claim.
Are polyphenol supplements a good idea?
Usually not, and sometimes they are harmful.
Food and extract. The same compound behaves differently when a large amount arrives at once.
- Green tea. A European safety review concluded that green tea drunk as tea is generally safe. For green tea extract in capsules, it found that high intakes raised liver enzymes in trials. Rare cases of liver injury have been reported even with the drink.
- Turmeric. Turmeric in food is safe. Liver injury has been reported with concentrated turmeric and curcumin supplements, especially those combined with black pepper extract to increase absorption.
- Others. For most polyphenol capsules there are no long-term safety studies at all.
There is a simple reason for the difference. In food, polyphenols come in small amounts, bound up with fibre, and reach the colon slowly. A capsule delivers a large amount at once, often in a form designed to bypass the gut’s own limits.
If you take any herbal or plant extract, tell every doctor who treats you, and stop it if you develop yellow eyes, dark urine or unusual tiredness.
What is not yet known?
- Whether changing bacteria with polyphenols prevents disease. The trials measure bacteria and blood markers over weeks. None has followed people for years.
- How much is needed. No daily amount has been established for any polyphenol.
- Who benefits. Tests for urolithin or equol groups are research tools, not clinic tests.
- Indian foods. Jamun, ragi, kokum, curry leaves and most Indian spices have barely been studied in people for their effect on gut bacteria.
How do I eat more colour?
Count colours, not milligrams
Aim for three or more colours on the plate at lunch and dinner.
Keep the skins
Whole pulses, unpeeled fruit, brinjal with its skin.
Use whole spices and fresh herbs every day
Coriander, mint and curry leaves count as plants too.
Choose the whole fruit over the juice
The fibre and the skin stay with it.
Time your tea and coffee
Between meals if your iron is low.
Skip the capsule
Food first. No extract has been shown to do better.
Wine is sometimes promoted as a source of polyphenols. Alcohol has its own harms to the gut and liver, and grapes and berries carry the same family of compounds without it.
From my practice
I do not ask patients to learn the names of polyphenols. I ask them to look at their plate. If lunch is white rice, a pale dal and a fried snack, there is little for their bacteria beyond starch. If it has a green, something red or purple, a whole pulse and a spice tempering, the job is largely done.
The two things I do ask about are tea with meals in anyone whose iron is low, and any capsule bought for “antioxidants” or “for the liver”. I have seen more harm from the capsules than benefit.
| What this page says | How it is known |
|---|---|
| Absorption differs greatly between polyphenols, and gut bacteria break them down | A review of food sources and absorption |
| Cocoa flavanols raised bifidobacteria and lactobacilli | A crossover trial in 22 volunteers |
| Coffee raised bifidobacteria | A study of 16 volunteers, without a comparison group |
| People fall into three urolithin groups | Consistent findings across several human trials |
| Only some adults make equol | A review of human studies |
| A polyphenol-rich diet lowered a gut-lining marker and blood pressure | A crossover trial; 51 older adults completed it |
| Cranberry extract increased Akkermansia | Mice |
| Tea and coffee reduce iron absorption from a meal | Iron absorption measured directly in adults |
| High intakes of green tea extract raise liver enzymes | A European safety review of trials |
Who should be careful?
- Low iron, pregnancy, or iron tablets: keep tea and coffee away from meals and from the tablet.
- Thyroid hormone tablets: take them as your doctor advised, apart from coffee.
- Reflux: coffee, chocolate and chilli worsen heartburn in many people.
- Irritable bowel syndrome: onion and garlic are common triggers, however good their polyphenols.
- Liver disease: avoid plant extracts and herbal liver capsules unless your liver doctor agrees.
When should I see a doctor?
See a doctor for tiredness, breathlessness or pallor that could mean low iron, and promptly for yellow eyes or dark urine, especially if you have been taking a herbal or plant supplement.
Questions patients ask me
Is green tea better than ordinary chai?
Both contain polyphenols. Green tea has been studied more. Neither has been shown to treat a gut condition. If you enjoy chai, there is no need to switch. Watch the sugar.
Does adding milk cancel the benefit of tea?
For iron, milk made little or no difference in the study: tea reduced iron absorption with or without it. Whether milk changes tea’s other effects is not settled.
Is dark chocolate good for gut bacteria?
The trial used a cocoa drink high in flavanols, not a chocolate bar. Chocolate also brings sugar and fat. A small piece of dark chocolate is a pleasure, not a treatment.
Should I take a curcumin or green tea capsule?
Not for general health. Use turmeric and tea as food and drink. Concentrated extracts have caused liver injury in some people.
I eat pomegranate every day. Am I getting the benefit?
You are getting the fruit, its fibre and its other compounds. Whether you make urolithins depends on your bacteria, and there is no clinic test for that. It is still a good fruit to eat.
Do polyphenols count as prebiotics?
The expert panel lists them as candidates. They meet part of the definition: bacteria use them, and they shift the community. What is still missing for most of them is proof of a health benefit in people.
Sources
This page is written for patients and is based on the guidelines and studies below. It is for education and does not replace a consultation.
- Review of the food sources of polyphenols and how they are absorbed. Manach C et al. Am J Clin Nutr. 2004. doi:10.1093/ajcn/79.5.727
- Review of how polyphenols and gut bacteria act on each other. Cardona F et al. J Nutr Biochem. 2013. doi:10.1016/j.jnutbio.2013.05.001
- International consensus statement on the definition of prebiotics. Gibson GR et al. Nat Rev Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2017. PubMed 28611480
- Randomised double-blind crossover trial of cocoa flavanols and gut bacteria in 22 volunteers. Tzounis X et al. Am J Clin Nutr. 2011. doi:10.3945/ajcn.110.000075
- Study of three cups of coffee a day and gut bacteria in 16 volunteers. Jaquet M et al. Int J Food Microbiol. 2009. doi:10.1016/j.ijfoodmicro.2009.01.011
- Pilot trial of mixed spices at cooking doses and gut bacteria. Lu QY et al. Nutrients. 2019. doi:10.3390/nu11061425
- Study of three urolithin-producing groups across human trials. Tomas-Barberan FA et al. J Agric Food Chem. 2014. doi:10.1021/jf5024615
- Review of equol and its formation by gut bacteria. Setchell KD, Clerici C. J Nutr. 2010. doi:10.3945/jn.109.119776
- Randomised crossover trial of a polyphenol-rich diet in older adults. Del Bo’ C et al. Clin Nutr. 2021. doi:10.1016/j.clnu.2020.12.014
- Study of a cranberry extract in mice on a high-fat, high-sugar diet. Anhe FF et al. Gut. 2015. doi:10.1136/gutjnl-2014-307142
- Study of tea, coffee, cocoa and herb teas and iron absorption from a meal in adults. Hurrell RF et al. Br J Nutr. 1999. PubMed 10999016
- European Food Safety Authority opinion on the safety of green tea catechins. EFSA ANS Panel. EFSA J. 2018. doi:10.2903/j.efsa.2018.5239
- Case series of liver injury from turmeric supplements. Halegoua-DeMarzio D et al. Am J Med. 2023. doi:10.1016/j.amjmed.2022.09.026
- Study of coffee and the absorption of thyroid hormone tablets. Benvenga S et al. Thyroid. 2008. doi:10.1089/thy.2007.0222
- American Gut citizen-science study of diet and the microbiome. McDonald D et al. mSystems. 2018. PubMed 29795809