Microbiome learning path · Chapter 15
Ayurveda and the gut microbiome
Ayurveda placed digestion at the centre of health many centuries before anyone had seen a bacterium. Its advice on when to eat, what to eat in each season and how to keep the bowels regular is still followed in most Indian homes. This chapter sets each teaching beside what is now known about gut bacteria. For each one it gives what Ayurveda says, how this may work in modern terms, and what studies have and have not shown. It closes the learning path.
In short
- Ayurveda’s advice on routine, meal timing and seasonal eating fits well with what is now known about the body clock and about gut bacteria.
- Agni, the digestive fire, is a single idea for work that modern medicine divides between acid, enzymes, bile, gut movement and gut bacteria.
- Buttermilk, spices and triphala each have a plausible way of acting on gut bacteria. Trials in people are few and small.
- Studies of prakriti find small differences in gut bacteria between constitution types. They do not yet guide treatment.
- Some Ayurvedic preparations contain lead, mercury or arsenic, and some herbs injure the liver. Tell your doctor what you take.
Can an old system and a new science be compared?
They can, as long as each is read for what it is.
Ayurveda describes what was observed over centuries in people who ate, slept and lived in particular ways. It has no instruments, and its classical texts do not describe gut bacteria as they are now understood. Microbiome science measures bacteria in great detail and, as the earlier chapters show, has few trials that change what happens to patients.
So neither proves the other. This chapter takes each teaching in three steps.
Three steps. The same order is used for every teaching on this page.
A review in 2024 of Ayurvedic therapies and the microbiome reached a plain conclusion: the research is at an early stage.
Is agni the same thing as the microbiome?
As Ayurveda describes it
- Agni is the power to digest food and turn it into the body’s tissues. It is described in four states: balanced, irregular, sharp and slow.
- Grahani is described as the seat of agni: the part of the gut that holds food until it is digested and then releases it.
- When agni is disturbed, grahani is said to release food undigested. The disorder is described as stools that are sometimes loose and sometimes hard, with undigested food in them.
How this may work. Modern medicine has no single measure that matches agni. It divides the work.
One idea, five parts. What Ayurveda calls agni, modern medicine measures separately.
Acid, enzymes and bile break food down. The muscle of the gut moves it along. Bacteria in the colon then ferment what human enzymes cannot digest, and make the short-chain fatty acids that fuel the colon’s lining. See chapter 1. In that sense gut bacteria are part of what Ayurveda calls agni, although the texts do not name them.
The description of grahani disorder resembles what doctors now call irritable bowel syndrome and, in some people, poor absorption of food.
Where the two differ. Agni cannot be measured, so it cannot tell slow stomach emptying from gallstones or coeliac disease. Tests can. See agni and modern gastroenterology.
What about ama?
As Ayurveda describes it
- Ama is the residue of food that agni has not fully digested. It is described as heavy and sticky.
- It is held to be the starting point of many diseases. A thick coating on the tongue is read as one of its signs.
How this may work. No substance matching ama has been identified or can be tested for. It is tempting to compare it with the fragments of bacteria that reach the blood in the mouse experiments of chapter 10. That is an analogy. Nobody has tested it.
What studies show. Ayurveda’s purification procedures, panchakarma, are meant to remove ama. The 2024 review found too few studies to draw any conclusion about their effect on gut bacteria. For the tongue, see a coated tongue and the gut.
Does the daily routine suit gut bacteria?
As Ayurveda describes it
- The daily routine is called dinacharya.
- Rise early, and pass stool in the morning.
- Eat the main meal at midday, when agni is strongest. Eat a light dinner, early.
- Eat and sleep at regular times.
How this may work. The gut, the liver and the gut bacteria all keep a daily clock.
The day, twice over. Ayurveda’s routine, and the modern finding that sits beside each part.
- In mice and in people, gut bacteria rise and fall through the day in step with meal times. Jet lag disturbed that rhythm.
- In 10 security officers, the proportions of the main groups of gut bacteria differed after night shifts compared with day shifts.
- In a 12-week trial, women who ate a large breakfast and a small dinner lost more weight and had better blood sugar than women who ate the same calories the other way round.
Where the literature disagrees. Timing has limits. In a 12-month trial of 139 people with obesity, restricting eating to a set window added nothing significant to eating less. And no trial has tested whether dinacharya as a whole changes gut bacteria. See gut bacteria, mood, stress and sleep.
Does eating by the season make sense?
As Ayurveda describes it
- The seasonal routine is called ritucharya.
- Food and habits change with each season. Agni is said to be weakest in the rains and strongest in winter.
- The food of the season and of the place is preferred.
How this may work. Two things change with the season: the infections in water and food, and the plants on the plate. The first is covered in stomach trouble in the monsoon and summer. The second reaches the gut bacteria.
- The gut bacteria of the Hadza, hunter-gatherers in Tanzania, change with the seasons as their food changes.
- In 60 members of a farming community in North America whose diet is the same all year except for fresh produce in summer and autumn, the gut bacteria shifted between winter and summer.
Where the literature is silent. These studies show that gut bacteria follow the food that a season provides. Nobody has tested Ayurveda’s regimen for each season against any other way of eating.
What about buttermilk, ghee, spices and triphala?
Buttermilk
Ayurveda: takra is advised after meals and in grahani disorders, often with roasted jeera and rock salt. How this may work: it is a fermented milk with live bacteria, little lactose, fluid and salt. Studies: a diet rich in fermented foods raised the variety of gut bacteria in a ten-week trial. I could not find a trial of buttermilk itself and gut bacteria in people.
Ghee
Ayurveda: the foremost of the fats used in food, taken in small amounts. How this may work: fat in a meal releases bile and prompts the colon to move. Studies: the published reviews are narrative, and no trial shows an effect of ghee on gut bacteria in people. See cooking oils and ghee.
Spices
Ayurveda: ginger, jeera, ajwain, black pepper and hing kindle the appetite and help digestion. How this may work: their plant compounds reach the colon, where bacteria act on them. Studies: a pilot trial found that mixed spices in cooking amounts changed the mix of gut bacteria. In a pilot of 14 people given turmeric, its extract or placebo, the response differed from person to person. See Indian spices and the gut.
Fasting
Ayurveda: fasting until true hunger returns is the first remedy for slow agni. How this may work: a gap without food lets the gut’s cleaning wave run. Studies: fasting changes gut bacteria, and nobody can yet say whether those changes matter. See intermittent fasting and the gut.
Triphala shows why a laboratory result is not a result in people.
Dish and person. A clear effect in stool cultures, and a different response in each person.
- In the laboratory. When triphala was added to cultures of human stool, bacteria that make butyrate increased.
- In people. In a four-week trial, 31 healthy adults took triphala, another herb or a placebo. Gut bacteria changed, but differently in each person.
Its mild laxative effect is better supported. See triphala for constipation.
Do people of different prakriti have different gut bacteria?
As Ayurveda describes it
- Prakriti is a person’s constitution, set at birth by the proportions of three doshas: vata, pitta and kapha.
- It is used to choose food, routine and treatment for the individual.
- Satmya is what a particular body is used to. Food that suits one person may not suit another.
How this may work. Modern studies agree that people differ. Identical meals raise blood sugar by very different amounts in different people, and gut bacteria are part of the reason. See chapter 11.
What studies show. Three Indian studies have compared the gut bacteria of healthy people of different prakriti.
Three studies. The overall mix was shared. A few bacteria differed by prakriti.
- In a rural population in western India, the overall make-up of the gut bacteria was similar across the three types, and certain species were more abundant in one type or another.
- In a study of 18 people, a handful of bacterial groups differed between types.
- In a study of 272 healthy people, a core set of bacteria was shared by all, with some bacteria found more often in one type.
What cannot be said. These are studies of association in healthy people. Prakriti is assessed by questioning and examination, and people of different prakriti may also eat differently. No study has tested whether food or treatment chosen by prakriti changes gut bacteria or improves any outcome. No stool test can tell you your prakriti.
What should I be careful about?
Food and routine are safe. Medicines are a different matter.
Heavy metals. Some Ayurvedic preparations contain metals or minerals by design, a practice called rasa shastra. Others are contaminated.
Three surveys. Lead, mercury or arsenic were found in a substantial share of the products tested.
- Of 70 products made in South Asia and sold in the shops of one American city, 14 contained lead, mercury or arsenic.
- Of 193 products bought online, about one in five contained these metals. Products made in the United States and in India were alike. Rasa shastra medicines contained metals twice as often as the others.
- Of 42 preparations bought from licensed shops in one Indian city, mercury was above the international limit in 29, arsenic in 6 and lead in 2.
The liver. In a study of 1,288 Indian patients with liver injury caused by medicines, complementary and alternative medicines were the second commonest cause.
What follows from this.
- Tell every doctor you see about every herbal or Ayurvedic preparation you take.
- Do not take preparations that contain metals or minerals unless a qualified Ayurveda physician has prescribed them and is monitoring you.
- Be especially careful in pregnancy, in children, and with liver or kidney disease.
- Do not stop a prescribed medicine in favour of a herbal one without asking the doctor who prescribed it.
- Stop the preparation and see a doctor for yellow eyes, dark urine, itching, loss of appetite or new abdominal pain.
Where do the two agree, and where do they differ?
Ayurveda’s teaching
- Digestion is the root of health
- Eat the main meal at midday and keep regular hours
- Eat the food of the season
- Take buttermilk and freshly made fermented foods
- Use spices to help digestion
- Each person is different
- Agni, ama and the doshas explain disease
- Purification procedures remove ama
What studies of gut bacteria add
- Gut bacteria make substances that act on the gut lining, the immune system and metabolism
- Gut bacteria keep a daily rhythm that follows meals. Night shifts and jet lag disturb it.
- Gut bacteria shift as the food of the season changes
- A diet rich in fermented foods raised the variety of gut bacteria
- Early pilot trials only
- Responses to the same food differ widely between people
- No measurable equivalent has been found
- Too few studies to say anything about gut bacteria
How do I use this?
Keep the routine
Regular times for meals and sleep, the main meal at midday and an early, light dinner.
Eat the season’s vegetables and fruit
Variety through the year feeds a wider range of gut bacteria. See fibre and the Indian plate.
Keep buttermilk and curd in the diet
Freshly set, and handled cleanly. See fermented foods.
Cook with spices
In the amounts used in food.
Treat herbal medicines as medicines
Ask who prescribed it, what is in it and for how long it is to be taken.
Move
Yoga is taught here as personalised yoga therapy. See yoga for IBS and constipation.
From my practice
I advise much of what Ayurveda teaches about routine: regular meals, the main meal at midday, an early dinner, buttermilk, and food that is freshly cooked. It costs nothing, and it agrees with what I know of the gut.
I ask every patient which herbal and Ayurvedic preparations they take, and I check liver tests when I am unsure. Ayurvedic medicines are for a qualified Ayurveda physician to prescribe. When symptoms persist, I investigate them as I would in anyone.
| What this page says | How it is known |
|---|---|
| Research on Ayurveda and gut bacteria is at an early stage | A review published in 2024 |
| Gut bacteria follow a daily rhythm set by meals | Mice and small human studies |
| A large breakfast and small dinner gave more weight loss than the opposite | A 12-week randomised trial in women |
| A fixed eating window added nothing to eating less | A 12-month randomised trial in 139 people |
| Gut bacteria shift with the seasons | Studies of Hadza hunter-gatherers and of 60 people in a farming community |
| A diet rich in fermented foods raised the variety of gut bacteria | A ten-week randomised trial |
| Triphala increased butyrate-making bacteria | Human stool cultures in the laboratory |
| Triphala changed gut bacteria differently in each person | A placebo-controlled pilot trial in 31 healthy adults |
| A few gut bacteria differ by prakriti | Three Indian studies of healthy people, of 18 to 272 people |
| About one in five Ayurvedic products contained lead, mercury or arsenic | Two surveys of 70 and 193 products |
| Mercury was above the limit in 29 of 42 preparations | A survey in one Indian city |
| Complementary medicines were the second commonest cause of medicine-related liver injury | A study of 1,288 Indian patients |
When should I see a doctor?
See a gastroenterologist for stools that stay loose or irregular for more than three to four weeks, for undigested food in the stool with weight loss, and at once for blood in the stool, black stools, difficulty swallowing or jaundice. A change of routine is not a substitute for a diagnosis.
Questions patients ask me
Is agni the same as the gut microbiome?
No. Agni is Ayurveda’s name for the whole power of digestion. Gut bacteria do one part of that work, in the colon. The texts do not describe bacteria.
Can a stool test tell me my prakriti, or my dosha imbalance?
No. Studies have found small differences in gut bacteria between prakriti types, across groups of people. They cannot classify one person, and no report can measure a dosha.
Is buttermilk a probiotic?
It is a fermented food that carries live bacteria. A probiotic is a named strain that has been shown in studies to benefit health. Buttermilk is a good food, and it has not been tested in that way.
Does triphala improve gut bacteria?
In stool cultures it increased bacteria that make butyrate. In a trial in healthy adults the changes differed from person to person. Its effect on constipation is better supported.
Are Ayurvedic medicines safe because they are natural?
Not always. Surveys have found lead, mercury or arsenic in a substantial share of products, and some herbs injure the liver. Tell your doctor what you take.
Will panchakarma reset my gut bacteria?
That has not been shown. A review in 2024 found too few studies to draw any conclusion.
Sources
This page is written for patients and is based on the guidelines and studies below. It is for education and does not replace a consultation.
- Review of Ayurvedic therapies and the microbiome. Vijayanna ST et al. Altern Ther Health Med. 2024. PubMed 38401105
- Study of the daily rhythm of gut bacteria and jet lag in mice and people. Thaiss CA et al. Cell. 2014. doi:10.1016/j.cell.2014.09.048
- Study of gut bacteria in 10 workers on day and night shifts. Mortas H et al. Chronobiol Int. 2020. doi:10.1080/07420528.2020.1778717
- Trial of a large breakfast against a large dinner in women with metabolic syndrome. Jakubowicz D et al. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2013. doi:10.1002/oby.20460
- Review of the timing of food intake and obesity. Garaulet M, Gomez-Abellan P. Physiol Behav. 2014. doi:10.1016/j.physbeh.2014.01.001
- Twelve-month trial of calorie restriction with or without time-restricted eating. Liu D et al. N Engl J Med. 2022. doi:10.1056/NEJMoa2114833
- Study of seasonal change in the gut bacteria of Hadza hunter-gatherers. Smits SA et al. Science. 2017. doi:10.1126/science.aan4834
- Study of seasonal change in the gut bacteria of 60 members of a communal farming population. Davenport ER et al. PLoS One. 2014. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0090731
- Trial of high-fibre and fermented-food diets and immune status. Wastyk HC et al. Cell. 2021. PubMed 34256014
- Review of ghee in Ayurveda and modern science. Kataria D, Singh G. J Ayurveda Integr Med. 2024. doi:10.1016/j.jaim.2023.100819
- Pilot trial of mixed spices at cooking doses and gut bacteria. Lu QY et al. Nutrients. 2019. doi:10.3390/nu11061425
- Placebo-controlled pilot study of turmeric and curcumin and gut bacteria in 14 healthy adults. Peterson CT et al. J Evid Based Integr Med. 2018. doi:10.1177/2515690X18790725
- Review of triphala in functional gut disorders. Tarasiuk A et al. Chin Med. 2018. doi:10.1186/s13020-018-0197-6
- Laboratory study of triphala and two other herbs in human stool cultures. Peterson CT et al. J Altern Complement Med. 2018. doi:10.1089/acm.2017.0422
- Placebo-controlled pilot trial of triphala and gut bacteria in healthy adults. Peterson CT et al. J Altern Complement Med. 2020. doi:10.1089/acm.2020.0148
- Study of gut bacteria and prakriti in a rural population of western India. Chauhan NS et al. Front Microbiol. 2018. doi:10.3389/fmicb.2018.00118
- Study of gut, mouth and skin bacteria and prakriti in 18 healthy people. Chaudhari D et al. J Biosci. 2019. PubMed 31719221
- Study of gut and mouth bacteria and prakriti in 272 healthy people. Shalin TV et al. J Biosci. 2021. PubMed 34148877
- Survey of heavy metals in 70 Ayurvedic herbal products sold in shops in one US city. Saper RB et al. JAMA. 2004. doi:10.1001/jama.292.23.2868
- Survey of lead, mercury and arsenic in 193 Ayurvedic medicines bought online. Saper RB et al. JAMA. 2008. doi:10.1001/jama.300.8.915
- Survey of heavy metals in 42 Ayurvedic preparations from licensed shops in Chandigarh. Bhalla A et al. Toxicol Res (Camb). 2022. doi:10.1093/toxres/tfab124
- Indian Network of Drug-Induced Liver Injury: causes and outcomes in 1,288 patients. Devarbhavi H et al. J Clin Exp Hepatol. 2021. doi:10.1016/j.jceh.2020.11.002
- Review of liver injury associated with traditional Indian Ayurvedic herbs. Philips CA et al. World J Hepatol. 2020. doi:10.4254/wjh.v12.i9.574