Gut bacteria
The “microbiome diet” for weight loss: what holds up
Several popular diets promise weight loss by repairing gut bacteria. They usually have three parts: remove a list of foods, add fermented foods, fibre and supplements, and then maintain. Some of this is good advice under a new name. More plants, more fibre, fermented foods and less processed food help weight and health. Other parts go beyond the evidence: cutting out gluten, dairy, eggs and grains for everyone, and taking probiotic capsules to lose weight. Gut bacteria do differ between lean and overweight people. Changing them has not yet been shown to produce lasting weight loss.
In short
- People with obesity tend to have a different mix of gut bacteria from lean people.
- That does not prove that the bacteria cause the weight, or that changing them reduces it.
- The parts of “microbiome diets” that work are the ordinary ones: more fibre and plants, fermented foods, less processed food.
- Cutting out whole food groups for everyone is not supported.
- No probiotic has been shown to produce meaningful, lasting weight loss.
What do these diets usually ask you to do?
Remove
Sugar and processed food, and often gluten, dairy, eggs, soy and most grains as well.
Replace and add
Fermented foods, prebiotic vegetables, and usually a list of supplements: probiotics, enzymes, acid tablets and herbs.
Maintain
A relaxed version of the same plan for life.
Which parts hold up?
Supported by good studies
- Less ultra-processed food. In a trial where people lived in a research unit, they ate about 500 kcal a day more on an ultra-processed diet and gained weight.
- More fibre from vegetables, fruit, pulses and whole grains. Higher fibre intake is linked with lower weight and less disease.
- Fermented foods. A diet rich in them increased the diversity of gut bacteria in a trial.
- Eating slowly and regularly.
Not supported
- Removing gluten, dairy, eggs, soy and grains for everyone. These help only people who have a specific intolerance or disease.
- Probiotic capsules for weight loss. Guidelines do not recommend probiotics for this.
- Enzymes, acid tablets and herbal “antimicrobials” for people who have no diagnosed need for them.
- The promise that weight lost this way is permanent.
Do gut bacteria control weight?
The idea comes from sound research. In a well-known study, the gut bacteria of obese mice extracted more energy from food, and transferring those bacteria to lean mice made them gain fat.
In people, the picture is less clear.
- Donor stool. In a small trial, 22 people with obesity took capsules of stool from lean donors or a placebo. Blood sugar and insulin after a meal changed in the transplant group. Trials of this kind have not established weight loss.
- A single bacterium. In a pilot trial, a supplement of one bacterium improved some markers of metabolism in overweight volunteers. It was a small, early study.
- Personalised diets. Researchers were able to predict each person’s blood sugar response to a meal from their gut bacteria and other measures, and a diet based on those predictions lowered blood sugar after meals. This is promising, and it is about blood sugar, not weight.
So gut bacteria take part in how the body handles food. They are one factor among many, with sleep, activity, medicines, hormones and how much is eaten.
One factor among many. Gut bacteria sit beside sleep, activity, medicines, hormones and how much is eaten.
What do I advise for weight?
- Eat mostly home-cooked food built on vegetables, pulses, whole grains, curd, nuts and fruit.
- Keep packaged snacks, sweets, fried food and sweet drinks for occasions.
- Do not remove a food group unless a test or a careful trial of exclusion shows that you need to.
- Do not spend on supplements sold for weight loss through the gut.
- If your weight is harming your health, ask about treatments with strong evidence. See weight-loss treatment.
Questions patients ask me
Can a stool test tell me which diet will help me lose weight?
Not at present. Commercial microbiome reports cannot yet prescribe a diet for weight. See what a stool or microbiome test can tell you.
I lost weight on a “gut reset” diet. Does that prove it works?
Such diets remove sugar, snacks and many calories, so weight falls. The loss comes from eating less, and it lasts only as long as the change in eating lasts.
Are fermented foods enough to lose weight?
No. They are good for the gut and belong in the diet. They do not cause weight loss on their own.
Does a “leaky gut” make me gain weight?
The link is studied in the laboratory, and it has not been shown to cause weight gain in people.
Sources
This page is written for patients and is based on the guidelines and studies below. It is for education and does not replace a consultation.
- Study of the gut microbiome and energy harvest in obesity. Turnbaugh PJ et al. Nature. 2006. PubMed 17183312
- Placebo-controlled pilot trial of donor stool capsules in 22 people with obesity. Allegretti JR et al. Hormones (Athens). 2021. doi:10.1007/s42000-020-00265-z
- Study predicting each person’s blood sugar response to meals. Zeevi D et al. Cell. 2015. doi:10.1016/j.cell.2015.11.001
- Pilot trial of Akkermansia muciniphila in overweight volunteers. Depommier C et al. Nat Med. 2019. doi:10.1038/s41591-019-0495-2
- Inpatient randomised trial of ultra-processed and unprocessed diets. Hall KD et al. Cell Metab. 2019. doi:10.1016/j.cmet.2019.05.008
- Trial of high-fibre and fermented-food diets and immune status. Wastyk HC et al. Cell. 2021. PubMed 34256014
- Systematic reviews of carbohydrate quality and human health. Reynolds A et al. Lancet. 2019. PubMed 30638909
- Salerno experts’ criteria for non-coeliac gluten sensitivity. Catassi C et al. Nutrients. 2015. PubMed 26096570
- American Gastroenterological Association guideline on probiotics in digestive disorders. Su GL et al. Gastroenterology. 2020. PubMed 32531291
- Trial of a once-weekly GLP-1 medicine in adults with overweight or obesity (STEP 1). Wilding JPH et al. N Engl J Med. 2021. PubMed 33567185