Symptoms and conditions
Is it harmful to hold in stool or gas?
Putting off a bowel movement now and then does no harm. Doing it day after day slows the whole colon, makes stool harder and can start a pattern of constipation. Holding in gas is not dangerous, but it causes bloating and discomfort. The remedy is simple and costs nothing: answer the urge when it comes, and give the bowel a regular time each morning.
In short
- The urge to pass stool is a signal that the rectum is full. If it is ignored, it fades, and the stool stays where it is.
- In an experiment, healthy people who held back for a week passed stool less than half as often, and food took almost twice as long to travel through the gut.
- Stool that waits in the colon loses water and becomes harder to pass.
- Holding in gas is uncomfortable but not harmful.
- The habit can be rebuilt in a few weeks.
What does Ayurveda say?
As Ayurveda describes it
- Ayurveda lists thirteen natural urges, called vega, that should not be held back. They include the urges for stool, urine and gas, and also hunger, thirst, sleep, sneezing and yawning.
- Holding back stool is said to cause pain in the abdomen, bloating, headache and a heavy feeling.
- Holding back gas is said to cause distension, pain and tiredness.
- The advice is equally firm that urges should not be forced. One should not strain to pass stool when there is no urge.
How this may work. The experiment described below shows the mechanism clearly: when the urge is put off, the whole colon slows, stool dries and the next urge comes later. Retained gas stretches the bowel, which is felt as distension and pain.
What happens when you ignore the urge?
When stool reaches the rectum, the rectum stretches and you feel the urge. If the time is not convenient, the muscles at the outlet tighten and the urge passes.
The stool does not disappear. It is pushed a little way back and waits. The colon goes on drawing water out of it, so it becomes drier and harder. If this is repeated often, the rectum learns to hold more before it signals, and the urge comes less often.
What did the experiment show?
Researchers asked healthy volunteers to live normally for a week and, in another week, to hold back their bowel movements for as long as they could.
A normal week
- About 9 bowel movements
- About 29 hours for food to travel through the gut
A week of holding back
- About 4 bowel movements
- About 53 hours
The slowing was not only at the outlet. The first part of the colon, on the right side of the abdomen, slowed down too. The researchers concluded that a habit of holding back can produce the same changes in the colon that are seen in constipation.
Who gets into this habit?
People with no time in the morning
An early commute or school run means the urge after breakfast is put off, and by the evening it has gone.
People who avoid toilets outside the home
At work, while travelling, or where toilets are not clean or private.
Children
A child who has had one painful stool often starts holding back. This is the commonest cause of constipation in children.
People with a painful condition
Piles or a fissure make passing stool painful, so it is put off, and the harder stool that follows hurts more. See anal fissure.
Is holding in gas harmful?
Passing gas many times a day is normal. Gas that is held back stays in the bowel for a while and is passed later, often during sleep.
In people who are prone to bloating, gas that stays in the bowel causes distension and discomfort. In a study of such patients, gentle exercise helped the bowel to move the gas along and eased the symptoms. A short walk does the same.
How do I rebuild the habit?
Choose a time
Fifteen to thirty minutes after breakfast suits most people, because the colon is most active then.
Sit properly
Feet on a low stool so that the knees are above the hips, leaning forward a little. On an Indian toilet the squatting position already does this.
Give it a few minutes, without straining
If nothing happens in five minutes, get up and try again after the next meal. Leave the phone outside.
Answer the urge at other times
When it comes, go as soon as you reasonably can.
Support it with food and water
Fibre from vegetables, fruit and pulses, and enough water. See water first thing in the morning.
Most people notice a change within two to four weeks.
See a doctor if you have
- Blood in the stool, or black stools
- Constipation that is new after the age of 45
- Weight loss you cannot explain
- Severe pain, vomiting or a swollen abdomen
- No improvement after a month of the steps above
Questions patients ask me
Can holding in stool cause piles?
Not directly. Holding back leads to harder stool and straining, and those contribute to piles and fissures.
My child refuses to pass stool. What should I do?
This is common and treatable. A stool softener prescribed by the child’s doctor, a relaxed toilet routine after meals and praise for sitting, not for the result, are the usual steps. Please see a paediatrician.
Is it bad to hold in gas during a meeting?
No. It will pass later. If it happens often and causes pain, look at what is producing the gas.
I never feel the urge. Is that a problem?
It can be a sign that the rectum has become used to holding more, or that the pelvic floor muscles are not relaxing properly. A simple test called ano-rectal manometry can tell which.
Sources
This page is written for patients and is based on the guidelines and studies below. It is for education and does not replace a consultation.
- Study of deliberately holding back bowel movements in healthy volunteers. Klauser AG et al. Dig Dis Sci. 1990. doi:10.1007/BF01536418
- American Gastroenterological Association and American College of Gastroenterology guideline on chronic constipation. Chang L et al. Gastroenterology. 2023. PubMed 37211380
- Indian consensus on chronic constipation in adults. Ghoshal UC et al. Indian J Gastroenterol. 2018. PubMed 30617919
- European and North American guideline on constipation in infants and children. Tabbers MM et al. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr. 2014. doi:10.1097/MPG.0000000000000266
- Study of mild physical activity and the clearance of intestinal gas in people with bloating. Villoria A et al. Am J Gastroenterol. 2006. doi:10.1111/j.1572-0241.2006.00873.x
- Study of normal flatus production in healthy volunteers. Tomlin J et al. Gut. 1991. doi:10.1136/gut.32.6.665
- Systematic review of fibre for haemorrhoid symptoms. Alonso-Coello P et al. Am J Gastroenterol. 2006. PubMed 16405552
- American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons guideline on anal fissures. Davids JS et al. Dis Colon Rectum. 2023. PubMed 36321851