Microbiome learning path · Chapter 2
The gut microbiome across a lifetime
Nobody is born with a gut microbiome. It is acquired at birth, built over the first three years, and then kept, largely unchanged, for decades. It shifts in pregnancy, it is disturbed by antibiotics, and in old age it follows what a person eats and where they live. This chapter follows the gut community from the first day to the last decades, and looks at what stool from non-industrial peoples, and from people who lived a thousand years ago, shows about what modern life has changed.
In short
- A baby’s gut is colonised at birth, mostly with bacteria from the mother.
- The community builds over the first three years and then settles into an adult-like pattern. This was the same in children on three continents.
- In adults it is stable. Most strains stay with a person for years, and family members share strains.
- It shifts during pregnancy, and it can be left changed by repeated courses of antibiotics.
- In old age it follows diet and living conditions. People in long-stay care had less varied bacteria and more frailty.
- Stool from people living traditionally, and from a thousand years ago, holds bacteria that industrial populations have largely lost.
How does the gut microbiome change through life?
Six stages. The two long stable stretches are the first three years, when it is built, and adult life, when it is kept.
The sections below follow that line from top to bottom.
Where do the first bacteria come from?
From the mother and the surroundings, at birth.
A baby born vaginally first carries bacteria that resemble the mother’s vaginal and bowel bacteria. A baby born by caesarean first carries bacteria resembling those of skin. Breast milk then feeds particular bacteria, because it contains sugars that the baby cannot digest and bifidobacteria can.
These differences are real and they narrow with time. A caesarean, formula or an antibiotic is sometimes exactly what a mother or baby needs.
When does a child’s gut community settle?
At about three years of age.
The first three years. The community changes fastest in infancy and levels off at about three.
Researchers compared 531 people of all ages in the Amazon region of Venezuela, in rural Malawi and in cities of the United States. In all three places the gut community matured over the first three years of life, with the same broad changes, including in the bacterial genes that make vitamins. A study that followed 903 children found the same timing.
The three populations ended up in different places, though. The gut bacteria of people in the United States differed markedly from those in Venezuela and Malawi, and the difference was visible from early infancy.
So the timetable appears to be human. What fills it depends on where and how a child lives.
Do pets, farms and the outdoors matter?
There is evidence that they do, mostly from studies of allergy.
- Pets. In 746 Canadian infants, those in homes with furry pets had more of two groups of gut bacteria that other studies have linked with less allergy and obesity.
- Farms. Two farming communities in the United States with similar ancestry and ways of life differ strikingly in childhood asthma. The community that follows traditional farming practices has far less. Dust from those homes protected mice from allergic asthma.
These studies concern the immune system more than the gut, and they show associations. They do fit a wider picture: a child’s immune system is trained by the microbes it meets early. They are not a reason to buy a dog or to avoid soap.
How stable is an adult’s gut microbiome?
Very. When 37 adults were followed for up to five years, most of their bacterial strains stayed with them throughout, and the researchers estimated that most strains remain for decades. Family members shared strains. Unrelated people did not.
Diet shifts the proportions within days, but the cast of strains changes little. This is why a short course of anything rarely leaves a lasting mark, and why what is lost in adult life is hard to regain. See chapter 1.
What happens during pregnancy?
The gut community changes, and the change appears to be part of a healthy pregnancy.
In 91 pregnant women, gut bacteria changed markedly between the first and the third trimester. When bacteria from the third trimester were given to mice raised without bacteria, the mice laid down more fat and became less sensitive to insulin than mice given first-trimester bacteria.
In someone who is not pregnant those would be warning signs. In late pregnancy they may help to supply the growing baby, and the researchers suggested that the change is useful. It is a reason not to “correct” a pregnant woman’s gut bacteria with supplements or restrictive diets.
What do antibiotics do over a lifetime?
Each course disturbs the community, and recovery is not always complete.
- After a single course in healthy adults, most bacteria return within one to two months. In one study, nine common species were still missing after six months.
- When volunteers took two courses of the same antibiotic, variety fell within three to four days each time. The community began to recover a week after each course, but the return was often incomplete, and by the end it had settled into a state different from where it started.
Antibiotics save lives and should be taken when they are needed. The point is to avoid the courses that are not. See restoring gut bacteria after antibiotics.
What happens to the gut microbiome in old age?
It becomes more individual, and it follows the plate.
Where and how an older person lives. Diet, bacteria and frailty moved together.
- Diet and setting. In 178 older adults, gut bacteria grouped according to where people lived: at home, in rehabilitation or in long-stay care. Their diets grouped in the same way. People in long-stay care had less varied bacteria, and loss of the bacteria seen in people living at home went with greater frailty.
- The very old. In a study that reached people over 105, a core of common gut bacteria shrank with age. Those who lived longest kept, or gained, certain groups that are associated with health.
- Changing the diet. In 612 older people in five European countries, a year on a Mediterranean-style diet changed gut bacteria. The bacteria that increased with the diet went with less frailty, better thinking and lower markers of inflammation.
These are associations. An older person who is unwell eats less widely, and both the illness and the diet change the bacteria. What the studies support is modest and practical: keeping variety and fibre in an older person’s diet is worth the effort.
What has modern life changed?
More than was suspected.
Three kinds of gut. Ancient and traditional communities resemble each other more than either resembles ours.
- People living traditionally. The gut bacteria of the Hadza, hunter-gatherers in Tanzania, change with the seasons. Some groups disappear in one season and return in the next. Those same groups are the ones that are reduced or missing in industrial populations.
- People who lived long ago. Researchers recovered bacterial genomes from eight samples of human stool between 1,000 and 2,000 years old. They resembled the gut bacteria of non-industrial peoples today more than those of industrial populations. They also carried far fewer genes for resistance to antibiotics.
- A possible mechanism. In mice carrying human gut bacteria, a low-fibre diet over four generations caused the loss of bacterial groups that did not return when fibre was restored. That is a mouse finding.
Nobody knows yet whether the missing bacteria matter for health, or whether they could be restored. It is a reason for humility about what counts as a normal gut, and one more argument for fibre.
How is the vaginal microbiome related to the gut?
It is a separate community with a simpler structure.
In 396 healthy women, vaginal bacteria fell into five types. Four were dominated by one kind of lactobacillus, which keeps the vagina acid. The fifth had fewer lactobacilli and more of other bacteria, and was also found in healthy women.
The link with the gut runs in both directions. The bowel is the reservoir for many of the bacteria that reach the vagina and the bladder, and a mother’s vaginal and bowel bacteria are her baby’s first. See recurrent urine infections and gut bacteria.
What can I do at each stage of life?
In pregnancy and infancy
Accept the delivery, feeding and medicines that are medically needed. Breastfeed if you can.
In early childhood
A wide range of foods from the family plate, time outdoors, and antibiotics only when prescribed for a clear reason.
In adult life
Fibre and variety every day. Avoid antibiotics you do not need.
In later life
Protect variety in the diet. Soft food need not be low-fibre food: dal, cooked vegetables, ripe fruit and curd all count.
From my practice
I see the two ends of life in my clinic more than people expect. Young parents worry that a caesarean or an early antibiotic has harmed their child for good. I tell them that the first three years offer a great deal of time to build a healthy gut community through food, and that the birth is one influence among many.
With older patients, the pattern I watch for is a diet that has quietly narrowed to tea, biscuits, rice and a little dal, often after an illness or the loss of a spouse. Widening that plate again is usually the most useful thing I can do for their bowels.
| What this page says | How it is known |
|---|---|
| The gut community matures over the first three years, on three continents | A study of 531 people; a study of 903 children |
| Pets in the home change an infant’s gut bacteria | A study of 746 Canadian infants |
| Most strains stay with an adult for years | 37 adults followed for up to five years |
| Gut bacteria change between early and late pregnancy | A study of 91 women, with transfer to mice |
| Repeated antibiotics can leave the community changed | Volunteers given two courses |
| In older adults, diet, bacteria and frailty move together | A study of 178 people; a one-year diet study in 612 |
| Bacteria that cycle with the seasons in hunter-gatherers are reduced in industrial peoples | 350 samples from the Hadza over a year |
| Ancient stool resembles non-industrial guts | Eight samples 1,000 to 2,000 years old |
| Fibre loss over generations can be lasting | Mice, over four generations |
When should I see a doctor?
For an infant or child: poor weight gain, blood in the stool, persistent vomiting or diarrhoea. For an older person: a change in bowel habit, weight loss, blood in the stool or a falling appetite. These need a diagnosis, whatever the state of the gut bacteria.
Questions patients ask me
My child was born by caesarean. Has the chance been missed?
No. The differences at birth narrow over the first years, and food and family life shape the community throughout that time.
Can I rebuild my gut bacteria as an adult?
You can change what your resident bacteria do, and their proportions, quite quickly through diet. Adding strains that are no longer there is much harder, which is why it is worth protecting what you have.
Should I take a probiotic in pregnancy?
Not for the purpose of changing your gut bacteria. The change that happens in pregnancy appears to be normal. Ask your obstetrician about any supplement.
Do older people need a probiotic?
There is no evidence that a routine probiotic helps. A varied diet with fibre and a fermented food does more.
Should we live more like hunter-gatherers?
No. Their bacteria reflect their food, water and surroundings, and so do their infections. The useful lesson is narrower: eat more plants, and more kinds of them.
Sources
This page is written for patients and is based on the guidelines and studies below. It is for education and does not replace a consultation.
- Study of how birth by caesarean or vaginal delivery shapes a newborn’s first bacteria. Dominguez-Bello MG et al. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2010. doi:10.1073/pnas.1002601107
- Study of gut bacteria in 903 children from 3 to 46 months of age. Stewart CJ et al. Nature. 2018. doi:10.1038/s41586-018-0617-x
- Study of gut bacteria across age in 531 people in Venezuela, Malawi and the United States. Yatsunenko T et al. Nature. 2012. doi:10.1038/nature11053
- Study of gut bacteria in 471 Swedish children from birth to five years. Roswall J et al. Cell Host Microbe. 2021. doi:10.1016/j.chom.2021.02.021
- Study of household pets and gut bacteria in 746 Canadian infants. Tun HM et al. Microbiome. 2017. doi:10.1186/s40168-017-0254-x
- Study of immunity and asthma in 60 children of two farming communities. Stein MM et al. N Engl J Med. 2016. doi:10.1056/NEJMoa1508749
- Five-year study of the stability of gut bacteria in 37 adults. Faith JJ et al. Science. 2013. doi:10.1126/science.1237439
- Study of gut bacteria through pregnancy in 91 women. Koren O et al. Cell. 2012. doi:10.1016/j.cell.2012.07.008
- Study of gut bacteria after two repeated antibiotic courses in volunteers. Dethlefsen L, Relman DA. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2011. doi:10.1073/pnas.1000087107
- Study of gut bacteria recovery in healthy adults after antibiotics. Palleja A et al. Nat Microbiol. 2018. PubMed 30349083
- Study of diet, gut bacteria and health in 178 older adults. Claesson MJ et al. Nature. 2012. doi:10.1038/nature11319
- Study of gut bacteria in people of extreme old age. Biagi E et al. Curr Biol. 2016. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2016.04.016
- One-year Mediterranean diet study of gut bacteria and frailty in 612 older people. Ghosh TS et al. Gut. 2020. doi:10.1136/gutjnl-2019-319654
- Study of seasonal change in the gut bacteria of Hadza hunter-gatherers. Smits SA et al. Science. 2017. doi:10.1126/science.aan4834
- Study of bacterial genomes recovered from human stool 1,000 to 2,000 years old. Wibowo MC et al. Nature. 2021. doi:10.1038/s41586-021-03532-0
- Study of a low-fibre diet over four generations of mice carrying human gut bacteria. Sonnenburg ED et al. Nature. 2016. doi:10.1038/nature16504
- Study of the vaginal microbiome in 396 women. Ravel J et al. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2011. doi:10.1073/pnas.1002611107